On This Day

66 Years Ago Today, Patsy Cline Reluctantly Recorded the Song That Would Become Her Signature Hit

On this day (November 16) in 1960, Patsy Cline stepped into Nashville’s Bradley Studios and recorded “I Fall to Pieces”. Penned by Hank Cochran and Harlan Howard, the lovelorn tale of a woman trying unsuccessfully to move on from a failed relationship has practically become synonymous with the late county music legend. Not only did “I Fall to Pieces” top the U.S. country charts, it also climbed to No. 12 on the pop charts, cementing Cline’s status as perhaps country music’s first-ever crossover queen.

However, Cline wasn’t the writers’ first choice to record the now-timeless classic. And even she initially had misgivings, worried that it was “too pop” for her country singing style. Fortunately, producer Owen Bradley persuaded her to give it a try โ€” giving the Virginia-born songbird her first-ever No. 1 hit and country music enthusiasts a sentimental standard that remains just as moving six decades later.

Videos by American Songwriter

Patsy Cline Initially Asked to Record the Songโ€”But Then Had Doubts

In the summer of 1960, Hank Cochranโ€”then a song-plugger for Pamper Musicโ€”stopped by his friend Harlan Howard’s Nashville home and asked for his help with a song he was writing.

“He then sang me the first two lines of the songs and I liked it,” Howard wrote prior to his death in 2002 at age 74. “So in the next hour we wrote it.”

It was too short, so Howard added another verse. His wife, country singer Jan Howard, recorded a demo of the song, which the two men took to Decca Records executive Owen Bradley. Impressed, he first pitched “I Fall to Pieces” to Brenda Leeโ€”but she turned it down, claiming it was too “country” for her pop sound.

Next, Bradley brought the song to upstart country singer Roy Drusky, who also nixed it for being too feminine. Patsy Cline happened to be in the studio hallway at that time, and she asked to record “I Fall to Pieces” after overhearing their conversation.

“It Was Just Like Satin”

However, Patsy Cline had second thoughts about “I Fall to Pieces” once she arrived at Bradley Studios on November 16, 1960.

The Jordanairesโ€”a popular Nashville vocal quartet who rose to fame backing Elvis Presleyโ€”were there to sing harmony, and Cline worried their voicesย would drown hers out. She also wasn’t fond of the emerging “Nashville sound”, which favored complex string arrangements over rougher-sounding steel pedal guitars.

Those reservations didn’t stop Cline from delivering the vocal performance of a lifetime, however. โ€œOnce Patsy got into the groove, she just caressed those lyrics and that melody so tenderly that it was just like satin,” Howard later recalled. “We knew we had magic in the can when, on the fourth take, every grown man in that studio was bawling like a baby.โ€

It Wasn’t an Instant Hit

Released in January 1961, “I Fall to Pieces” wasn’t exactly an overnight success for Patsy Cline. It didn’t reach the U.S. country charts until April, beginning a slow ascend to No. 1 by August.

[RELATED: 3 Songs That Show Why Patsy Cline Was One of Countryโ€™s Greatest Voices]

Appearing on Cline’s sophomore album Showcase, “I Fall to Pieces” also reached No. 12 on the pop charts. The song’s success earned the singer an invitation to the Grand Ole Opry, where she would perform “I Fall to Pieces” no less than 14 times in 1961.

Featured image by Johnny Franklin/andmorebears/Getty Images