The Cheap Malfunctioning Guitar That Led to the Smashing Pumpkins’ Classic “Mayonaise”

Don’t get us wrong, great music is made deliberately. However, occasionally, a mistake or accident comes around that creates something a musician could never think of. This is exactly what happened with Billy Corgan and The Smashing Pumpkins on their alternative song “Mayonaise.”

Videos by American Songwriter

If one is familiar with Corgan and The Smashing Pumpkins, they know that the band is all about experimentation. They are not looking for that perfect sound, but are looking for that sound that is new, innovative, and unfamiliar. That being so, when Corgan and the band recorded “Mayonaise,” they embraced the “problem” that took place in the studio.

The Smashing Pumpkins and the Whistling Guitar

If you listen to “Mayonaise” you can hear a bellowing and piercing whistle embedded between every pause of the song. As deliberate as it ended up being, it did not start that way. Rather, Corgan had to work around a guitar hardware malfunction, and needless to say, he did so exceptionally well.

In an interview on Apathy Video, Corgan explained the nuance behind the whistling malfunction and how it led to the unique writing process behind “Mayonaise.” “The origin of the squealing high note was, I bought this guitar for $65 and it’s such a cheap guitar that every time I’d stop playing it would make that whistle.” “So when we wrote the song, you wrote in these parts that would stop,” stated Corgan. “The whistle became part of the song because every time I’d stop it would whistle” and “then we started using the whistle to our advantage,” added Corgan.

Other than this being a cool piece of Smashing Pumpkins’ trivia, the story is also an example of how a great musician is not defined by their instrument. Instead, a great musician is defined by how they work with any given instrument. Billy Corgan and The Smashing Pumpkins are an ideal example of that notion, and their alternative rock single proved that to be true.

Released in 1993 on their second studio album, Siamese Dream, “Mayonaise” remains a staple in The Smashing Pumpkins’ catalog. There are certainly a vast amount of reasons behind the song’s positive public reception. However, the whistle’s novelty is surely a part of its decorated nature. There are only a couple of bands that could turn a problem into a pro, and of course, Billy Corgan and The Smashing Pumpkins are one of them.

Photo by Paul Bergen/Redferns