Four and a Half Fingers Didn’t Stop Jerry Garcia From Becoming One of the Most Innovative Guitarists of All Time

The Grateful Dead pioneered live recording, introduced jam band music to the mainstream, and created arguably the most staunch and devoted fanbase of all time. In short, they are truly one of the most successful bands of all time, and they achieved this feat through their original tactics. Well, they also achieved this feat thanks to their four and a half fingered frontman, Jerry Garcia.

Videos by American Songwriter

Yes, Jerry Garcia, the famed guitarist for The Grateful Dead, only had four and a half fingers. Despite this inconvenience, Jerry Garcia still became one of the most novel and unique guitarists to ever do it. Given Jerry Garcia and The Grateful Dead’s success, this fact might seem trivial, as it seemingly did not hinder his playing in the slightest. Though, regardless, it’s pretty impressive that Jerry Garcia learned how to play guitar with only four working fingers on his right hand. Which was his strumming hand, arguably the more important hand when it comes to playing guitar.

How Jerry Garcia Lost His Finger and How It Changed His Way of Playing

The story behind Garcia’s lost finger is not at all epic in the slightest. Rather, it is fairly relatable, as it involves a young Garcia, his brother, and an axe. As the story goes, Jerry Garcia lost a significant portion of his right middle finger while chopping wood with his brother. Reportedly, Garcia was around four to five years old at the time of the accident, and they were fooling around when the accident transpired.

10 or so years later, Jerry Garcia would go on to learn guitar. Garcia never strictly stated that his lack of a finger led to his unique playing style. Though he did have a unique playing style, particularly in the way he held the pick. “The way I hold the pick is a bit strange, I guess. I don’t hold it in the standard way but more like you hold a pencil,” Garcia told Guitar Player in 1978.

Again, Garcia didn’t deliberately state that he held his pick this way due to his missing finger, but most people typically don’t hold a guitar pick that way. Nevertheless, the accident evidently did not hinder Garcia’s ability in the slightest, and it likely even impressed his fans even more. In short, Jerry Garcia is one of the best to ever do it, and while everybody had 10 fingers, he only had nine.

Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images