Country music is full of songs that signal their dark content with minor-key arrangements and vocal deliveries that match the tone. However, that’s not always the case. Some songs will have listeners tapping their feet and grooving to the upbeat instrumentation until they listen to the lyrics a little more closely.
Videos by American Songwriter
The dark country songs below fit that mold. There’s a lullaby with a threatening omitted verse and jaunty tunes that hide stories of murder, abuse, addiction, and betrayal.
[RELATED: 4 of the Best Murder Ballads in Bluegrass History]
1. “You Are My Sunshine” by Gene Autry
Many people believe “You Are My Sunshine” is a sweet, cheesy song. Parents across the country sing the song’s chorus to their kids on a regular basis. However, country legend Gene Autry released a version of the song in 1940 that contains an often-omitted verse that makes this sweet little ditty incredibly dark.
I’ll always love you and make you happy / If you will only say the same. / But if you leave me to love another / You’ll regret it all someday, Autry sings. The “regret” is open to interpretation. It could either be “you’ll never have anyone treat you as well as I do,” or “If I can’t have you, no one can.” Either way, it adds some darkness to the otherwise happy song.
2. “Tom Dooley” by Doc Watson
To be fair, a long list of bluegrass or old-time songs would fit this list. Those offshoots of the country genre are full of songs that sound happy but have dark undertones. Doc Watson’s version of the Appalachian murder ballad “Tom Dooley” is a perfect fit, though. Just listen to that opening harmonica solo and the otherwise jaunty arrangement. It’s a certified toe-tapper.
The lyrics, though, aren’t so happy. The song recounts the murder of Laura Foster and the hanging of Tom Dooley, both of which really happened. As the story goes, Dooley was innocent. Moreover, he lied on the stand to protect the real killer–the third person in a deadly love triangle–because he didn’t want to see her hang. Before going to the gallows, Dooley maintained his innocence but agreed that he deserved to be hanged.
3. “Goodbye Earl” by The Chicks
The Chicks included this fun Dennis Linde-penned track on their smash hit 1999 album Fly. There’s no denying that this song is a ton of fun. The arrangement, the vocal delivery, and Linde’s writing make this song a great time, even with the murder plot that sits on the surface.
However, if country fans were to read the lyrics, the song gets dark. The Chicks’ infectious delivery makes the story about domestic abuse and murder sound much happier than it really is.
4. “I Love Doing Drugs” by The Devil Makes Three
“I Love Doing Drugs” appears on The Devil Makes Three’s most recent album, Spirits, and it sounds incredibly fun. The arrangement and delivery make it sound like the song’s narrator is recalling a few wild nights he shared with his pals. Sure, he’s using illicit substances, but it’s no big deal. Right?
By the end of the song, we learn that he’s not just using substances to have a good time. Instead, the song lays out a set of self-destructive behaviors that end with the narrator losing everything to his addiction.
Featured Image by Kobal/Shutterstock
Leave a Reply
Only members can comment. Become a member. Already a member? Log in.