Features

The One Song Elton John Stopped Playing Live Due to a Broken Heart

โ€œEmpty Garden (Hey Hey Johnny)โ€ was penned by Elton John and his longtime songwriter Bernie Taupin back in 1982. The song was featured on the album Jump Up! and is one of the most successful singles from the album. Itโ€™s also considered one of Johnโ€™s most underrated tracks to date. And sadly, the song has some heartbreaking connotations, which is why John has rarely ever played it live.

โ€œEmpty Gardenโ€ was written about former Beatles star John Lennon, who was Johnโ€™s close friend and collaborator. Lennon was murdered in 1980, and โ€œEmpty Gardenโ€ was Johnโ€™s tribute to his beloved friend. He had even performed with Lennon at the latterโ€™s very last concert at Madison Square Garden a few years before his death.

Videos by American Songwriter

The Origins of Elton John’s โ€œEmpty Gardenโ€

According to Elton John, he was afraid of writing a song like โ€œEmpty Gardenโ€ for Lennon, as he thought a tribute song would end up being โ€œclumsy.โ€ However, Taupin changed Johnโ€™s mind when he showed him the lyrics he had come up with.

The music video for the song was similarly heartwrenching. It features John alone in a replica of John Lennonโ€™s home, solemnly performing the tune on his piano.

One notable performance of the song occurred in 1982 at Madison Square Garden with Yoko Ono and Sean Lennon in attendance. He played the song again later that year on Saturday Night Live.

Today, John has shelved lived performances of the song. During a concert back in 1999 in Madison, Wisconsin, John told the audience that performing the song brings back too many painful memories of the day of Lennonโ€™s death. He did perform โ€œEmpty Gardenโ€ in 2013 during his Las Vegas residency, but it hasnโ€™t been played live since. And thatโ€™s certainly understandable.

(Photo by Steve Morley/Redferns)

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.