These 3 Debated Country Classics Still Spark Arguments to This Day

Like any form of poetry, the meaning behind songs is up for debate. Even the most straightforward of songs can spark divergent opinions. The three country songs below are often debated for their morally murky storylines, their intent, or their old-fashioned ideals.

Videos by American Songwriter

[RELATED: On This Day in 1959, Johnny Horton Recorded the Best Country Song of the Year—a Humorous History Lesson From the Perspective of an American Soldier]

“The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia” (Reba McEntire)

Reba McEntire’s “The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia” features an anti-hero. And, like any narrative with this kind of character, the listener feels conflicted about whether to get on board with their decisions.

The narrator in “The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia” reveals herself to be a murderer at the end of this song. Though she does so out of vengeance for a loved one, does the reason justify the ends? That’s up for debate. Though this isn’t a widely held debate, it’s one every listener must grapple with as they go through this tale of revenge.

“Jolene” (Dolly Parton)

Dolly Parton’s “Jolene” is universally beloved, but its lyrics raise some gray areas that make it tough to analyze. While some listeners hear an impassioned plea, others hear blatant insecurity. Your smile is like a breath of spring / Your voice is soft like summer rain / And I cannot compete with you, Jolene, she sings in this country staple.

While Beyoncé’s more recent version of this song addresses some of the watered-down elements in Parton’s argument, something is intriguing about her earnestness. I guess whatever approach you want from this song, there is a version of “Jolene” for you to love.

[RELATED: 4 Country Artists Who Became Grand Ole Opry Members Later in Their Career]

“Stand By Your Man” (Tammy Wynette)

In a similar vein, there is some debate over whether Tammy Wynette’s “Stand By Your Man” strikes the right chord. Moreover, there is a debate over what Wynette intended for this song in general.

The line, And if you love him, oh, be proud of him / Cause after all, he’s just a man leads the listener to believe Wynette is being a bit facetious in this song. Others, however, take it as an earnest ode to romantic devotion that hasn’t aged well. Whatever the meaning and intent, this song has proven to be an era-defining country classic.

(Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images)