4 Country Stars From the 2000s Who Disappeared Without a Trace

Country stars come and go, but some country stars opt to straight-up disappear without a trace from country music stardom. And sometimes, those disappearances aren’t intentional; the music industry can be a pretty tough place, especially when it comes to career longevity. The following four country stars who made it big in the 2000s disappeared after their 15 minutes of fame, and we’re going to find out what they’ve been up to.

Videos by American Songwriter

1. Cyndi Thomson

Cyndi Thomson kicked off an impressive career at the turn of the millennium with her hit debut single “What I Really Meant To Say”. That track made it to no. 1 on several US charts. Her debut album also yielded a few subsequent successful singles, including “I’m Gone” and “I Always Liked That Best”.

Just two years later, Thomson left the music industry, citing that she couldn’t commit to it. She did co-write a few songs here and there after her retirement, and she released a couple of EPs in the late 2000s and 2010s. She performs off and on today, but it seems like her recording career is more or less over.

2. Cole Deggs

Remember Cole Deggs? This could-have-been country superstar was the frontman of Cole Deggs And The Lonesome. The band’s biggest hit was “I Got More” from 2007. Sadly, the band’s follow-up single didn’t see nearly as much success, and they were promptly dropped by their label. The band broke up by the end of 2007.

Deggs continues to write songs for other musicians today, and he also performs at local events in Texas. However, it doesn’t look like he records anymore.

3. Chris Cagle

It’s wild that Chris Cagle makes this list of country stars from the 2000s who disappeared. The man had five Top 10 hits in the early aughts (including “I Breathe In, I Breathe Out” and “Chicks Dig It”), and he seemed to be very popular. He enjoyed a pretty active touring career until the mid-2010s, too.

However, in 2015, Cagle announced that he was retiring. Specifically, he cited a need for a new career path that would make it easier to spend more time with his children.

4. Carolyn Dawn Johnson

Carolyn Dawn Johnson makes our list of country stars from the 2000s who disappeared, but she does (thankfully!) seem to be back in action nowadays.

Johnson is best known for writing Chely Wright’s no. 1 hit “Single White Female”. She was signed as a musician in the year 2000 and released her debut album in 2001. “I Don’t Want You To Go” and “Complicated” are just a couple of hits that Johnson scored.

Johnson has since taken a break from music, though it looks like she’s back in the game in the 2020s. She released several singles in the last few years, and there’s definitely potential for a comeback.

Photo by Jason Kempin/Getty Images

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.