The List

3 Classic Rock Album Covers That Critics and Fans Hated

A picture is worth a thousand words, and these classic rock album covers inspired a few choice words from fans and critics who hated them. Itโ€™s worth noting that we know people donโ€™t exist in a vacuum; you might actually enjoy a few of these album covers. I know I certainly do. However, they werenโ€™t very well-loved when they were released, so they do (unfortunately) deserve their spots on this list. Letโ€™s dive in, shall we?

1. โ€˜Born Againโ€™ by Black Sabbath

Quite a few people werenโ€™t happy about the album cover art for Black Sabbathโ€™s Born Again. Though, I doubt many of those people were fans. Who wouldnโ€™t expect a red demon baby on the cover of a Black Sabbath album? One could say a lot of the hate came from more conservative observers who found the cover to be blasphemous. 

Videos by American Songwriter

However, even the bandโ€™s own drummer and vocalist hated the cover. Bill Ward explicitly said that he hated it, and vocalist Ian Gillan said that the cover made him sick.

2. โ€˜Savedโ€™ by Bob Dylan

This unfortunate entry on our list of hated classic rock album covers could have been better. Bob Dylan is a visual creative as well as a musician, too. However, Dylan is not the artist behind the album cover art for Saved

Rather, he commissioned Tony Wright to do the artwork for him. He was told to put together a painting based on a โ€œvisionโ€ that Dylan had experienced of Jesusโ€™s blood-covered hand reaching for a group of people. Columbia Records was not happy about the cover, or the religion-heavy themes of the record.

3. โ€˜Metallicaโ€™ by Metallica

Donโ€™t get me wrong! This is a legendary album that influenced countless rock bands that followed in Metallicaโ€™s footsteps. However, one canโ€™t help but wonder what the band was thinking with that cover. 

This example of hated classic rock album covers features an all-black background with a cut-and-paste image of a snake and an almost completely ineligible โ€œMetallicaโ€ logo in the corner. Itโ€™s a creative mess, and itโ€™s kind of a miracle that the band got new fans from the cover alone.

Photo via YouTube

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.