3 Country Songs That Will Make You Rewind To Hear What They Just Said

Country songs have a knack for telling you like it is. Country singers are straight-shooters. There’s no time for mixed messages when the fields need plowing, and the roofs need mending, and the pigs need feeding, and there’s one on the way.

Videos by American Songwriter

But sometimes that truth-telling can go too far. Or at least be too specific. Sometimes it makes you utter the words, “What did that person just sing?” Well, that’s what we wanted to dive into here. These are three country songs that make you rewind to hear what they just said.

“Goodbye Earl” by Dixie Chicks from ‘Fly’ (1999)

There’s nothing quite like a catchy murder ballad to make you stop and wonder, “Wait, what am I singing along to?” Of course, there are lots of songs in history where one spouse is knocking off the other. And that’s just what this 1999 tune by The Chicks is all about. But not all of them are jangly like this one. If you didn’t know what you were singing, you might not think twice. But, oh well. Revenge is fun when it’s put to music, ain’t it?

“The Long Black Veil” by Johnny Cash from ‘Orange Blossom Special’ (1965)

This has to be one of the most beautiful songs ever written. It’s a great tale with a great reveal at the end. It’s like an M. Night Shyamalan movie wrapped up in three minutes. But because it’s so good and so tight, you have to make sure it’s saying what you think it’s saying. Indeed, Johnny Cash is singing about infidelity and the death penalty. Yes, a man is giving up his life to protect his love’s honor. What a story! Put it on again!

“Fancy” by Bobbie Gentry from ‘Fancy’ (1970)

Some songs present their listeners with a verse and a chorus, a verse and a chorus, and they’re done. Other tracks, though, paint an entirely special picture—they give listeners a vivid image and a plot line that makes you think. “Fancy” by Bobbie Gentry is most assuredly in the latter category. Gentry is one of country music’s best short story writers—you can tell just from this tune. It’s about a young girl whose mother spends her last dollar on a dress to make her look like a woman in the world. It’s sad, heartfelt, and rings too true. You have to hear it several times over to be sure it is what it is!

Photo by Beth Gwinn/Redferns