Rock songs are typically more upbeat than they are downers. Though different subgenres use sadness to their advantage, rock, at its core, is about energizing the listener. The three songs below do almost the opposite of that, breaking the mold of rock. These three rock songs are all deeply sad, with key details that twist the knife ever further.
Videos by American Songwriter
[RELATED: 4 Diane Warren Songs With Absolutely Devastating Lyrics]
“All My Love” by Led Zeppelin
Led Zeppelin’s “All My Love” is sad at face value, but it becomes even bleaker when you learn why Robert Plant penned this track. “Should I fall out of love, my fire in the light / To chase a feather in the wind / Within the glow that weaves a cloak of delight / There moves a thread that has no end,” Plant sings in this morose song, paying tribute to his son who passed away while the rock outfit was on tour.
Knowing this detail about this song makes the listener hear it in a new light. What was once just a sad song with, perhaps, breakup language is now a sob-worthy eulogy. It’s a tough listen once you learn of the tragedy that inspired it.
“Alone Again (Naturally)” by Gilbert O’Sullivan
This soft rock song is one of the most depressing tracks ever written. It’s heavy with loneliness and existential disappointment. But what really makes this song so agonizing is the mask of a cheery melody. This isn’t just a sad song; it’s a poem from a man who is resigned to misery. He’s not bargaining, and he’s not looking for catharsis.
“We may as well go home / As I did on my own / Alone again, naturally,” O’Sullivan sings in this downtrodden track. These lyrics over a traditionally sad melody would be one thing. These thoughts, beneath an upbeat musicality, are almost haunting.
“Fire And Rain” by James Taylor
James Taylor’s “Fire and Rain” is far sadder than many listeners give it credit for. This rock song has a nostalgic, comforting appeal. This makes it more of an every emotion kind of classic, rather than a somber ballad.
But when you dig into the lyrics of “Fire And Rain,” the listener is reminded of just how depressing this song can be. One of the saddest verses in this soft rock classic is, “Been walking my mind to an easy time / My back turned towards the sun / Lord knows, when the cold wind blows / It’ll turn your head around.” It speaks to the unpredictability of life with a sharp sting of grief.
Songfacts: Fire and Rain | James Taylor
A session musician named Bobby West played the upright bowed bass on this track, which is sometimes mistaken for a viola or cello. In a Songfacts interview with Peter Asher, he told the story: “We didn’t have a bass on the track and it was James’ idea to try bowed upright bass to create the drone of the bottom note. So, we asked the studio for a player because I was not familiar with most of the LA musicians. I’d put together a little rhythm section already, which was Carole King, who I’d got to know and loved her piano playing, and a drummer called Russ Kunkel, who I had found. But at that point, we had not found the perfect bass player, so we used different bass players on different songs. And, on that one, James’ idea was to use a bowed upright bass, so we asked around and they recommended this guy called Bobby West. Bobby ‘Wild Wild’ West, we discovered he was known, which clinched it for us. We thought that was such a cool name. So, we hired him and put the bass on and then I doubled the bass to give it that weird, slightly flangey effect, playing the exact same notes. And, those are the only strings on that whole album, I think.”
(Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images)
Leave a Reply
Only members can comment. Become a member. Already a member? Log in.