Remembering When Elton John and Bernie Taupin Devoted an Entire 1975 Album To Remembering Their Early Days

The songwriting partnership between Elton John and Bernie Taupin catalyzed John’s massive success throughout the early part of the 70s. About halfway through that decade, they decided they needed to assess whence they’d come.

Videos by American Songwriter

John’s 1975 album Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy served as a musical retelling of their pre-fame days. The album stands out from the other LPs in John’s catalog. That’s because it focuses on making a cohesive artistic statement rather than acting as a conduit for massive hit singles.

Looking Back

Elton John endured his share of personal ups and downs in the first half of the 70s. But in terms of his commercial success, the guy was pretty much a can’t-miss. You could reliably count on John to churn out a couple of huge hits from the LPs he released. And he tossed those LPs out to his fans at a ridiculously prolific pace.

But he and his lyricist Bernie Taupin sometimes felt as if they didn’t earn the same kind of critical respect for the albums they concocted. Many rock writers judged them more in terms of how their singles performed, which was usually very well. They wanted more than that.

They decided they’d try something new and create a concept album. Unlike other theme records from the rock era that focused on fantastical stories, John and Taupin would make theirs autobiographical. Specifically, they’d look back to the late 60s. That’s when their partnership formed, and they were looking to make it big.

Painstaking Effort

John and Taupin went all out in their efforts to achieve the effect of telling a complete story over two sides of an album. For one example, the songs were written and recorded in the order that they appear on the album.

The songs refer to the pair’s early days together, albeit in an occasionally oblique fashion. In terms of the album title, Captain Fantastic was meant to represent John, although it could be argued that he hadn’t yet assumed that mantle of fabulousness in his pre-fame days. Taupin was the Brown Dirt Cowboy, a reflection of his bucolic roots.

“Someone Saved My Life Tonight”, which recalled John bolting from a scheduled marriage, comes the closest to a literal blow-by-blow of what transpired in that era. Beyond that, Taupin mostly hints at the event while focusing on emotional truth, such as in the lovely “We All Fall In Love Sometimes”. John and his band went for ambitious arrangements but seemed to consciously steer clear of radio-friendly hooks.

‘Fantastic’ Voyage

Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy debuted at No. 1 in the United States upon its release in May 1975, continuing the commercial success upon which John could always rely. “Someone Saved My Life Tonight” was the breakout hit, despite its tortured subject matter.

But the critical love that John and Taupin had always sought was a little more elusive. The legacy of the album is complicated as well, as earlier John LPs like Goodbye Yellow Brick Road and Madman Across The Water have a much better consensus reputation these days.

The aftermath was messy. John fired two members of his longtime band. He then diluted the impact of the LP by rushing out the lightweight Rock Of The Westies just a few months later. Nonetheless, Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy serves just as well as any biography at capturing the heady beginnings of the John and Taupin partnership, even if it’s not quite as catchy of so much of the music they’d go on to create together.

(Photo by Allan Tannenbaum/Getty Images)