Velvet Underground recorded “Sweet Jane” in 1970. Throughout the decades, the song has undergone many transformations, some of which caused contention among the band members. Nevertheless, it has been called one of the greatest rock n’ roll songs. It is undoubtedly one of the group’s most memorable.
Videos by American Songwriter
But while few doubt its greatness, no one can quite figure out what it means. The lyrics, at times, seem to be a literal story about three real characters. However, as the song progresses, it delves into something much darker and more symbolic. Fans have long tried to take “Sweet Jane” apart, theorizing that it is about drugs, the rock n’ roll lifestyle, or a criticism of societal expectations.
The first stanzas tell a story of a happily domesticated couple, while the later stanzas reflect on human pain and suffering. As if to make interpretation even more complicated, The Velvet Underground recorded many versions of the song, switching the lyrical order or changing minor details. Simply, it is a track that defies interpretation.
Of course, fans have still tried to comb out the meaning of this legendary track. Here are some theories behind “Sweet Jane” and what the song could mean.
The Inspiration Behind The Song
There are several ideas about how Lou Reed created “Sweet Jane.” Some think that the name and character are based on a former girlfriend who became addicted to drugs and that Reed’s external observations reflect trying to love someone in the throes of addiction. Another story says that Reed was inspired after watching a film that depicted a little girl playing with a gun; he found the contrasting images of innocence and violence worth exploring.
Though no one can agree on how “Sweet Jane” came to be, one thing is sure: the song was undoubtedly Lou Reed’s attempt to write a smash hit for Velvet Underground. The effort paid off, and the track is one of the band’s most famous.
Themes In “Sweet Jane”
“Sweet Jane” explores many themes as an unnamed narrator observes a couple named Jack and Jane. The narrator may be from a different era than the couple; he describes them as wearing old-fashioned clothes and driving in a Stutz BearCat, a flashy car popular in the 1920s.
Jack is in his corset; Jane is in her vest
And me, I’m in a rock n’ roll band
Riding in a Stutz BearCat, Jim
You know, those were different times
In some ways, it seems Jane and Jack are an old-fashioned, happy couple. Jack works as a banker, and Jane as a clerk. Every night, they sit in front of the fire in their comfortable home and listen to classical music on the radio.
But “Sweet Jane” also suggests changes in the old-fashioned, conservative depiction of these characters. For one thing, they seem to be cross-dressing—a man wearing a corset, some have pointed out, is not traditional dress (though at least one recorded version swaps their clothing, putting Jack in the vest).
Although Jack and Jane listen to classical music, they also hear more ominous things on the radio:
Ooh, sittin’ down by the fire, oh
The radio does play the classical music there, Jim
The March of the Wooden Soldiers
All you protest kids, you can hear Jack say
Get ready
Who is Jane?
Fans have long been divided over the character of Jane. Some think she is a literal character—maybe an older, conservative woman threatened by the increasing popularity of the rock n’ roll lifestyle.
Others think that “Jane” may be a nod to drugs. Jane or Mary Jane was a common way to personify drugs in the rock industry. While it is true that the members of Velvet Underground were known to be heavy drug users, none have ever confirmed whether the depiction is accurate.
Another theory is that Jane is neither a real woman nor a concrete reference to any one thing. Instead, she embodies inspiration or creativity; in some sense, she is a muse figure for the protagonist “in a rock n’ roll band.”
Reed’s Departure & Versions
The Velvet Underground recorded several versions of “Sweet Jane,” each with minor differences. Most notable were two versions, the original from 1970 and a later live performance recording from 1972.
The latter included an additional bridge, which featured the lyrics:
Heavenly wine and roses
Seem to whisper to her when he smiles
Heavenly wine and roses
Seem to whisper to her, hey, when she smiles
Some fans have suggested that this ethereal addition supports the theory that Jane is a concept rather than a real person.
Legacy Of “Sweet Jane”
Ultimately, none of the members of The Velvet Underground—and certainly not Reed himself—ever clarified the true meaning behind “Sweet Jane.” It has been left to their generations of fans to interpret. However, Reed would be the first to say that feeling outweighs true meaning. In this way, the meaning of “Sweet Jane” isn’t as important as the emotions that the song evokes.
Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images
