3 Rock Bands That Completely Changed When a Member Left

A band is like an ecosystem. It’s a fine-tuned, calibrated situation that needs the precise amount of this or that to stay functional. If you change something dramatically, if you remove something significant, everything about the band dynamic could switch. Here below, we wanted to highlight three times when that proved to be true. We wanted to dive into the stories of three bands that changed it up midstream. Indeed, these are three rock bands that completely changed when a member left.

Videos by American Songwriter

Pink Floyd

Founded in London in the mid-1960s, Pink Floyd was originally led by songwriter and performer Syd Barrett. As Bob Dylan was wowing audiences with vivid protest songs and the Beatles were singing about driving cars and needing help, Pink Floyd was pushing boundaries with extended psychedelic music. That was largely thanks to Barrett. Under his leadership, the band released its debut album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, in 1967. But by 1968, Barrett left the group due to mental health struggles. With him gone, Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters took over, and Pink Floyd soon helped to solidify the 1970s classic rock sound with albums like The Dark Side Of The Moon (1973), Wish You Were Here (1975), Animals (1977), and The Wall (1979).

Van Halen

Founded in the early 1970s, Van Halen quickly grew to become one of the biggest and most bombastic rock bands of the 1980s. The group was fronted at first by singer David Lee Roth. But after a short time, tension started to grow between Roth and the band’s namesake guitarist, Eddie Van Halen. Roth wanted party rock while Van Halen wanted deeper, darker tunes. So, in the mid-1980s, Roth left the band. Van Halen then sought to find a new lead singer. Enter: Sammy Hagar, who took over in 1985. Hagar focused less on party rock and more on the range and power of his voice. It was almost as if the band grew up a bit as it switched vocalists.

Genesis

The British-born band Genesis got things started in the mid-1960s. At first, the group was fronted by singer Peter Gabriel. But in 1975, Gabriel decided to leave the band and focus on his growing solo career. All of a sudden, Genesis was left in the lurch. What to do? Strangely, they looked to their drummer. Phil Collins joined the band in 1970. But five years later, he would take on double duty. In 1975, with Gabriel’s departure, Collins took over lead singing duties. The result? Collins breathed new life into the group until he, too, departed in 1996, replaced by singer Raymond Wilson.

Photo by Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic